Saturday, 15 December 2012

The Royal Game of UR - Iteration Essay

The Royal Game of Ur

Introduction

In this essay it will focus on a ancient board game known as the Royal Game of Ur. The Royal Game of Ur was first discovered by Sir Leonard Woolley in the Royal Tombs of Ur in Mesopotamia in 1926-27. Though he found five different versions each one had different variations in the way it was decorated. The boards were all shaped of oblongs of 3x8 cells from which two cells have been taken away on each of the outer edges. All together there are 20 cells on a board. The boards were all decorated however differently in a mix of shells and jewels  mainly lapis lazuli. The cells on some boards depicted animal scenes though all the boards agree by having rosettes on the centre file and one on the side of the bridge. The more elaborate boards have rosettes on the 3x4 end. The boards date from around 3000bc. The board is also associated as similar or played the same as the Egyptian game sen't though has a different shaped board.The boards were hollow and inside contained seven black and seven white counters and six strange dice. The dice were of a pyramid shape and had 2 of the four corners coloured differently. There was three white and three lapis lazuli.



Appendix one


Body

According to Bell R.C he suggested that the game was played under the following rule set:

Each player would place an agreed sum into the games pool as a pot for the winner. To decide which player would go first one of the players would throw one of the dice and while it is in mid air would decide whether or not a marked corner would be pointing upward. Both players start with no counters on the board. The point at which the counters enter the board are shown on the diagram below(Bell, R.C (1979)). So the player that is going first throws his or her dice and the possible outcomes are three marked corners up would net you a score of five and another throw. Whereas three plain corners would get you a score of four and another throw. Two plain corners up would get you a score of zero and the turn finishes and one plain corner up would get you a score of one and another throw.

For a player to be able to place a counter on the board they would have to throw a five and then all throws after that would decide on how much the counter would move around the board. On the board  as shown in the diagram below you can see some marked squares. If a player lands his or her counter on this space then their opponent would have to pay a fine to them. On the board below there is a a central file which is where players are effectively at war with each other. If the current player moves a counter onto a square with another players counter on then the attacked players counter is removed from the board and can only be entered back into play with another successful score of five. A player can have as many of their counters on the board at any one time however they can only have a single piece in each of the games squares. The game is won when a player has managed to safely get all of their counters of the board. To do this a player must roll exactly the number of squares needed to land on the final square on the board.




Appendix two




Another common way of playing is for each player to decide who goes first. once whoever goes first is decided then that player rolls their dice. Depending on how many marked sides are pointing up is how many spaces a player can move his or her counter. For example if you roll a three then you can move one counter from outside of the board to the enter square which you can see in the appendix one. You would then move along the edge towards the first rosette or marked square  If you land a piece on the marked space at the end of your move then you would get a second roll and so on. Once you have reached the first marked square the next move takes you into the middle where you will do battle with your opponents pieces. If you or an opponent land their piece on a square containing yours or their counter then that counter is knocked of the board and back into the players hand. Unless however the players counter is in a marked square then it is safe. The counters in the marked squares cannot be knocked of the board and as a strategy a player can keep counters there which works not only by keeping that players counter safe but also by taking the chance of an extra roll from the other player. To win the game a player must get all their counters to the end of the board and land exactly on the last marked square. Players can also have more than one counter occupying one square and move them all as one however this can be risky as if a player lands his or her counter on that square then they would all be knocked back to the start.

Now for the purpose of this essay an iteration on the way the game is being played will be implemented and a discussion on how the new rule changes will affect the gameplay. There are allot of things to think about when making any kind of iteration to a game like positive and negative feedback loops, intention, perceivable consequence, skill, luck and also the victory condition. As the game stands there is some skill based decisions like whether or not to leave a counter on a marked square or whether to move your counters as a group. Even whether to put another counter on the board or whether to focus on moving a particular counter to the end. Though the game still focuses allot on luck as a player cannot definitively predict exactly what they will throw and so is at the mercy of the dice outcome. Also if a player happens to throw an amount which lands them exactly on a marked square which will give them a free roll. There is also a negative feedback loop in this game as it is with players having to land exactly on the last square which can take numerous turns and allow the opponent a chance to catch up.  

Now a simple iteration would be to allow for an extra dice and the splitting of the results between the player's pieces. The splitting of the dice results between the counters would allow another element of skill to be implemented and at the same time reducing the impact of luck on the game. Also it would reduce the impact of the negative feedback loop experienced towards the end of the board as if a player is 2 spaces away from the finish but rolls a four then a player could simply use two of the four rolled to get their counter safely of the board and the remaining two would allow them to move another of their counters. Though what is great about this iteration is that when a player is on their final counter then the negative feedback loop comes into play but is not as powerful as it was before as it only really affects the last piece but may be enough in a close game to allow the opponent feel that they have not lost yet and keep their tension up in the game so that the player remains emotionally invested in the game. Another great dynamic to come form this is the fact that a player can more easily strategically move their counters as to allow them to take control of the marked safe zones and stopping their counters from being removed form the board. A couple of issues arising from this iteration however was do we allow the extra roll usually awarded for landing on a marked square being that it is allot easier to land in these squares now and with having an extra dice would this make the game too quick. For the purposes of this though it was best to leave the awarded roll in play as that would be a further iteration and also it actually made the game play fast again but made players cautious at leaving these marked spaces open and made a nice strategy evolve where players would camp in the marked squares to deprive their opponent of extra rolls. As for adding one extra dice which will allow for a faster game where the tensions are high but are not drawn out so a player does not get too exhausted and will want to play the game again. This allows the game to more easily fit in a scoring system where the game result itself doesn't matter and that the amount of games won in a set more important. This is good for a player not loosing interest as that game was just one result of say a best of five game. If however the game was too long then it would usually focus down to the result of just one game as the player or players have little interest to play another game.

Conclusion

The iterations made to the Royal Game of Ur were interesting and it feels it not only balanced the game out in respect to the skill and luck but also made the game faster and added new dynamics in how the game could be played. The new strategies that emerged from the protection of the marked squares made some great play styles and bought out different emotions from players. So all in all I feel these iterations had a positive result on the game as a whole.

Wednesday, 28 November 2012

Group Project - Fall for Me

Group Project
Fall for ME



So our group decided to go for a game called Fall for Me. In this game we decided on going for an avoider type game. After doing our character concepts we decided to go for flying squirrels as they seemed like a good choice for our target audience age. Craig Knights did the character concepts of Syril and Sally the squirrels. 

This is Syril

This is Sally

I particularly like how Sally's wings look like a dress in this pic at the bottom. I also like the nice cartoon look of the squirrels also.

So in this project we use a task delegation system called Jira and we set our work out in one week sprints. In one of the first sprints I was tasked in creating some place holder art and code a background into the stage. Now they are only actually concept art and is not what we decided to use in the actual game. Just so I could get the code in place and also get a rough Idea what the game may look like with some art in. 

This is the art I created for the place holder. I basically put a variety of different size tree trunks in there and some pine trees in the distant background. It was to create the effect that Syril was falling down from a tree within the forest.

Here I simply extended the length of the background to be larger for the game

This is a very quick concept on what I thought the background scene may look like

This was a rough art for the avoidable branches that would spawn randomly on the left and right of the screen.


I then coded this in and created the place holder with background. I was then tasked in creating some code so that the character place holder would be able to move around the stage. 

For now the character place holder art is a red box MovieClip that responds to Boolean values of key presses to move the character smoothly. 

So on the next sprint the group was tasked with creating more background concepts and some asset design. 

Glen made some art but it was art more suited maybe for game cut scenes





This below is Glens asset designs for avoidables within our game.






Craig made some background art as well and it seemed to fit in with what we wanted quite well so as of now it is the art we are using for our first level.




As you can see the layout of this level worked rather well with the player being able to move in and out of the branches as well as avoiding the leaves that will be coming up also.

I then worked with Chris to code in some parts to get the game place holder functional.

A working place holder is available here http://www.waterfrontgames.com/game/index/47

In the next sprint I was tasked in creating a tutorial screen and some more coding tasks. Now Craig had already created A start menu screen so when I created a tutorial screen I wanted it to follow the same art style so I removed some of the layers in Craig's title screen and replaced it with tutorial relevant information. 



Lastly in this sprint me and Chris coded in some alternate movement for the character like mouse movement and added in some down and upward movement.











Tuesday, 20 November 2012

Robs Weekly Reading - Chance

Chance

Delaying or preventing solvability

What is meant by solvable? Solvable is when you can see all the possibilities of a game in front of you. Games like tic-tac-toe can get boring quickly because it is easily solved. Chess is another example of games with a solvable outcome exept that the field of possibilities is so large that it remains entertaining.

Competitive for all players

When playing  games like chess it is unsuitable for  family gaming because a player who is sufficiently skilled in chess would generally always win. This would be ok for some players as they would want compelling gameplay and the satisfaction that they played a better match. If all games were based around skill then it would result in allot of bored and frustrated children. With games like chess when a player looses he or she can see how they lost and where they made mistakes and not because of a random roll of the dice.

Increasing Variety

To increase variety in games you can have elements of random. Games like Settlers of Catan have a random setup and numerous ways in which you can build and in risk the random battles which the dice will mean you will have to change your strategies depending on the outcome.

Dramatic Moments

Dramatic tentions can be created when a players strategy and game outcome come
 down to say roll of the dice or another random element.

Enhancing decision making

 When a choice is clearly the right choice then it is not always exciting but enhancing the decision by having the chance of increased risk as well as payoff will make it much more exciting.

Mechanics of Chance

Dice

Dice come in various shapes and sizes  ranging from 1 to 100 sides. Dice add a good element of chance into a game with each throw of the dice having an equal chance to land on one of its sides. However when you start adding multiple  dices thats when the chances of getting certain results change. Getting eith a low result or high result with multiple dice becomes less likely and the result of rolling a middle number more likely

Cards

Cards are great for adding elements of chance and other mechanics into a game. They can be reshuffled randomizing their order. They can be placed face down on the table making their information hidden or only players can see what cards they have giving the player priveliged information.

Pseudo-Random number generators

Pseudo-random number generators are used by computers. They are complex algorithms used to create a close enough random number for games purposes

Hidden Information

Whe nonrandom information is concealed from players it is still random to the player just not the opponent. Similar to an RTS games fog of war.

Measured Randomness

When elements of randomness are known and can be planned for by the player.

Completely Random Games

There are two main types of completely random games.

Childrens games and gambling games

Generally these types of games have no skill at all and is completely random


Tuesday, 13 November 2012

liars dice

Liars dice


Ticking clock

The ticking clock is represented by the reduced number of dice in play.  Rounds will also start to get quicker.

Uncertainty 
The uncertainty in liars dice is represented by the fog of are essentially as people can not see each other's dice. You also don't know for certain if a players lying and what is actually there.

Inevitability

The inevitably I  liars dice is when a player holds the majority of the dice and knows roughly the true answer.

Feedback loops

This game features a positive feedback loop which is making the easier forth winner to win and the looser to then loose. Things done as mentioned before by a player in the lead having a majority of the dice and having a wider knowledge of what dice are in play.

A constant question players are asking is how many dice are in play. Now if people are not keeping track of the dice overall that information become essentially an advantage for a player. You can lie and say you have a certain amount dice or less than what you have and then your opponent will try to calculate the rough odds off that call being genuine however you have extra dice the opponent has forgot about.



Monday, 12 November 2012

Tools for creating Dramatic Game Dynamics

Tools for creating Dramatic Game Dynamics



Digital games have bought games and stories closer together then ever before.

Egyptian game of Senet which along with go is one of the oldest games known to humanity.

We cannot create drama directly, the way a storyteller scripts a story. Our task is a more indirect approach.

Mechanics, Dynamics and Aesthetics

Mechanics are the program code and all its equipment

Dynamics is essentially the behaviour of the game.

The relationship between dynamics and mechanics is one of emergence. A games dynamics emerge from its mechanics.

A games aesthetics are its emotional content.

Aesthetics can challenge our intellect or physical prowess. It can foster social interaction. It can stimulate our imagination. It can provide us with a vehicle of self-expression. A games aesthetics come from the games dynamics. So how the game behaves is how determines how a player feels. A games mechanics exist all the time even as the game is not being played. However a games dynamics manifest when the game is played. 

When playing we flow from mechanics to dynamics and then aesthetics.

Following the three tools that govern game development allows us to refine the motivating questions of our inquiry into drama in games.

  • How does drama function as an aesthetic of play?
  • What kinds of dynamics can evoke drama?
  • From what kinds of mechanics do those dynamics emerge?
The dramatic arc: Aesthetic Model for Drama

An aesthetic model of what drama is and how it happens.Tools used to formalise the design objectives.

Drama however is only one aesthetic from many.There are many more aesthetics to play a game each needing and with their own aesthetic model.



Dramatic arc

The dramatic arc is an aesthetic model for stories.

Drama as an Aesthetic

The dramatic arc is not a universal fact of all stories, but rather a desirable property of dramatic stories. The dramatic arc creates a frame of mind where individual moments become meaningful, powerful and relevant. 

Drama in games

All drama originates from conflict. Without conflict we will never have dramatic tension.

Dramatic tension is the product of two different factors:

Uncertainty: the sense the outcome of the contest is still unknown. Any player could win or lose.

inevitability: the sense that the contest is moving forward toward a resolution. The outcome is imminent.

Tension relies on these two factors in a combination-neither is sufficient by itself. So without uncertinty players merely become spectators and the outcome of the game merely becomes a forgone conclusion. Without inevitability on the other hand the outcome of the conflict seems distant. players are given little incentive to invest their emotions in the contest. 

Tension relies on these two factors in combination. 

Feedback Systems as Sources of Uncertainty 


Game State The complete status of a game at that particular moment i.e the data contained within a save file or the position and places of checkers pieces.

Scoring It is the rule of the game that gives us a numerical measurement of who is winning and by how much.

Game Mechanical Bias It is a rule of the game that gives one of the contestants an advantage over the other.

Controller It is the rule of the game that decides if the player receives the mechanical bias.

A good example of feedback systems used to alter the games dramatic feel and keep conflict interesting and uncertain is handicaps. Lets take a racing game fro example. If a player is loosing their top speed is increased so that they may have a chance to catch up to the player in front. This closing the gap and creating a much more dramatic feel.

Other sources of uncertainty

Pseudo-Feedback

Mechanics and dynamics that create the perception of negative feedback where one player takes the lead and the other players catch up however when we inspect the games mechanics no such cybernetic feedback system  are present.

Escalation

Dynamic scoring rate where more score is gained at the end of the game then at the start.

Decelerator

Attained by creating a slow part of a game where it gives the loosing players the illusion that they have closed the space between them and their opponent where in time measurement or score measurement for example their opponent is still in the lead by the same amount its just that they are closer to the player. As an example imagine a race with speed bumps both cars are racing around and one is clearly in the lead but gets to the speed bumps. Now the car in the front slows down to go over the speed bumps allowing the player behind to get close and feel they have caught up however then they also have to slow down and so the amount one is leading the other is the same in time in this instance however the distance is reduced creating the illusion of catching up though this still creates tension.

Cashing out

A method of scoring a game where the players are scored on best of say seven for example. Though each of these games have scoring also it makes no difference on the performance of ones score in a particular one of these games it is only a means of determining a winner for that stage. The loosing player still has an equal chance of winning overall no matter how bad they played in that previous round because it is just 1 of 7. Where as if that player had just one their forth game then that would be the win.


Positive and negative feedback

Positive

Helps bring the game to a climax. Preparing the winners to win and the looters to loose

Negative

Helps the loosing players reinvest their emotions. 

Feedback systems of real and illusory
Real are mechanics that affect how a looking player gets bias

Illusory 

Gives the feeling of a handicap however no mechanics actually in place to facilitate 






















Wednesday, 7 November 2012

Iterating an RTS

Rob's lesson notes
Creating a paper RTS

Our set reading for this lesson was all about a games MDA and I have notes on it in an earlier blog. The main point we focused on from the reading for the class task was to design a game but focusing on the aesthetics first instead of the mechanics. So we decided what we want a player to feel when playing our game then design a game round those aspects.

So we were handed a game to play test. In this game we had a hexagonal grid 


We played with four player with one player playing from each corner. 

We would also place various obstacles on the grid for players to manoeuvre around.

Now the main part of this game was the RTS(Real Time) aspect how this was accomplished was to have four types of cards

move

turn/move

turn

shoot

Now each player would have a set of these cards in their hand and would pick one and place their card face down. Now everyone would turn over their cards at the same time and reveal their move. So for example a player can move two places with a move card but only in the direction of their counter is facing hence the turn cards also a player can only shoot in the facing direction. We played this game for about 20 mins and realised that it was broken with its current set of mechanics. 

We found that players were camping and continuously shooting to not move now there was no way another player could get near them with the moves at their disposal and kill them so it left players in stalemates. Also the game went on way to long and conflict was very slow if it happened at all.

So after this we decided to iterate and make changes on an aesthetic start point. So we picked challenge.

To add challenge to the game we decided to give each of the players four troops to command each with their own different abilities

  1. - Soldier - 6hp, 3 range
  2. - Sniper - 4hp, 7 range
  3. - Medic - 5hp, 2 range, half damage, AOE heal
  4.  - Air - 7hp, 3 range, jumps over cover.
We played this iteration for a little while but quickly figured that with keeping the old move amounts the game dragged out again and we needed to speed up a player getting into conflict situations. We could of done this in two ways. One by reducing the size of the play board and two by increasing the amount of moves. We decided to increase the amount of moves you could make by adding counters. So players could pick up to three cards or play a single card three times or two cards and use one twice and one once etc. We made players show this by placing counters on top of the cards to how many times they want to use that card before turning it over to stop people just saying what they wanted to move depending on what their opponents picked.

We also added more strategically placed obstacles and a capture the flag system to create a point on the battlefield that all players would head for and make a nice conflict zone in the centre. 

We play tested this several times and it was definitely successful in adding the challenge aspect to the game however the game still lacked anything concrete to keep you interested. It is hard to play a good real time game in a non digital format but other things we could of added in any future iterations was the way the units moved or to go back to a single unit for a player and implement random weapon drop location that maybe gave players different types of shots. I believe also that this game would of played allot better in a turn based way with slightly different mechanics.